My aspiration to high-mindedness and my love of nice things have co-existed in constant tension for as long as I can remember.
I trace these early twin drivers to the following sources:
1) The life and work of Louisa May Alcott (Little Women! all those Transcendentalists she grew up with!)
2) My mother (glamorous black and white photos of her life in Los Angeles and San Francisco in the ’40s and ’50s! drawers full of cashmere sweaters! caviar and smoked oysters!)
The influences are entwined; my mom shared her stories of growing up during the Great Depression. She had two sweaters and one skirt to wear for school. Period. I can easily understand why she drifted to over-shopping later in her life- she could.
I over-shopped too, in my young adulthood. I was unrealistic and undisciplined for a while, and I suffered for it.
As I dug out from under debt (with the help of my mother, it is only fair to say) I developed a new strategy: I would buy less, but I would buy the best I could afford when I had the money, so that I would not feel poor when I did not.
This strategy is best applied to things that last. I am still happily using the pots and pans I purchased 25 years or so ago. I fretted about the expense at the time, but that cobalt enamel looks as good to me now as it did in nineteen-eighty-whenever.
The amount of time spent anguishing over a prospective purchase tends to be balanced by my resulting satisfaction. In the last year and a half, I have anguished over a new sofa, a side table and an area rug for the family room, a dresser for The Kid, and a bed and bedside table for the master bedroom. That sounds like a lot, and it is, but not so much when one considers that the sofa and bedside table are replacements for Craigslist stand ins, the wooden bed and headboard replace a basic metal frame, and the other pieces should have been there long ago. ( I also took considerable advantage of sale prices and/or my employee discount.)
And now I am ready to put on the brakes, thanks to some sort of inner equilibrium that shifts my attitude about spending from exhilaration to queasiness at just the right time. After a certain amount of consumption, I am driven to get back to work, and produce something.
I feel contented and supported when I see and use the things I’ve bought. They serve my family and me, and will for a long time, leaving me mental space to worry about bigger things.